+- Jewish Forums (https://www.thehebrewcafe.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Main Forums (https://www.thehebrewcafe.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Israel (https://www.thehebrewcafe.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=28)
+--- Thread: Israel Should Benjamin Netanyahu PM of Israel, resign over the Oct 7th 2023 Hamas attack? (/showthread.php?tid=1450)
Should Benjamin Netanyahu PM of Israel, resign over the Oct 7th 2023 Hamas attack? - Robert - 10-26-2024
Should Benjamin Netanyahu Prime Minister of Israel, be made to resign over the October 7th, 2023 Palestinian Arab Hamas barbaric attack and massacre?
No, not unless the reader would have thought it appropriate for Franklin D. Roosevelt (President of the United States from 1933 to 1945) to resign over the Japanese attack on Peal Harbor of December 7, 1941.
President Roosevelt's address to a joint session of the U.S. Congress on December 8 1941 is as appropriate a description today of Israel's circumstances following the Palestinian Arab Hamas attack, as it was for the United States' response to the Japanese attack on U.S. forces in Pearl Harbor in 1941.
Following President Roosevelt's accurate description of the attack on Pearl Harbor as:
'a date that will live in infamy',
the President went on to say:
Quote:'No matter how long it may take us to overcome this premeditated invasion, the American people in their righteous might will win through to absolute victory. I believe I interpret the will of the Congress and of the people when I assert that we will not only defend ourselves to the uttermost, but will make very certain that this form of treachery shall never endanger us again.'
Extract source:
https://www.history.com/topics/world-war-ii/pearl-harbor
RE: Should Benjamin Netanyahu PM of Israel, resign over the Oct 7th 2023 Hamas attack? - COmentator - 10-27-2024
Only if he refuses to do the following:
Liberate Judea and Samaria from the PLO
Liberate Gaza from the PLO
Liberate Sinai from Egypt/PLO
Liberate the last 20 living Jews from Lebanon
Liberate the last 8 living Jews from Syria
Account for the 3 Jewish MIAS abducted by Syria
Speaking of Syria
The fall of Assad is a disaster for Barack Obama
Obuma tried the same diplomatic responce on Iran,,,,,same worthless agreements with Iran who declares Israel, the United States part of the "Great Satan"
Update 1/25-26/2025
OH Israel....why are thou making the same mistakes of twenty Years ago?
2005: The Gaza "Disengagement" Plan - Chabad.org
How the left's missteps shaped Israel's struggles - JNS.org
Rabbi Schneerson warned of the consequences about giving up Jewish settlements and giving away Israel..he was so right
see Israel 365 News article Israel's Three Mistakes...15 November 2023
(Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 187).
https://www.chabad.org/library/article_c...s-Gift.htm
See online article Simchat Shmuel by Rabbi Sam Shor
The L-D's Will that the Jewish People do have a right to settle in the land of Israel-and the galut world nations refusal to acknowledge this right .and their rebellion against the Word of the L-D.
3,400 homes for Jews are being built in Judea and Samaria
I sincerely hope that for every 1 house built now that 12,000 more will be built! (including both sides of the Jordan River Valley)
I also hope that the last galat Jews in Iraq; Iran; Lebanon, Tunisa; Egypt, Syria , Ethopia, Turkey Europe and Russia take warnings from the Torah and Talmud and GO UP TO ISRAEL and Live as Jews
Yes you will get all the Hostages back [alive and dead]
But.....
Every Jewish Hostage released at a ratio of 50 PLO per Hostage [1904 PLOs to be released]
Palestinians shall be able to return to their homes in Gaza, and Israel would gradually withdraw from some (but not all) parts of the Gaza Strip
Israel would end the blockade of the Gaza Strip
Under the proposal, activities in the Gaza Strip would be supervised by Egypt, Qatar and the United Nations, who along with the United States would guarantee the proposal and its provisions. Hamas stated that they received promises that both Egypt and Biden would guarantee the implementation of the deal
Result:
Gaza Strip will be smaller...but Hamas/PLO will be vipers to strike at Israel.
Egypt 20 year old Treay is null and void due to Egypt failure to abide by the terms of the Treaty...{Rabbanic ruling that when one party to a agreement breaks it the agreement is null and Void]
Qatar is allied to Iran the same country that made it law that any Jew in Iran connected with Israel is subject to the death penalty
The United States is in such deep trouble as a result of Both l------y c-----n Biden who Bankrupt it and the i---t b-----n Trump who confused into Chaos it is not in any position to "police" Gaza
The United Nations and their so called Refugee section hate and loathe Israel
The 26 Jewish settlements in Gaza; the Sinai and Judea and Samaria cry out to be reestablished on Jewish Land...but Netanyahu has neither reestablished Jewish settlements...nor will he deport PLO/Hamas/PA out of Gaza. the Sinai; Samaria and Judea to Palestine/Jordan....
In short Israel may have won this war but they will never have Peace at the Hands of Ishamel and Esau'
20 Jews are still in Lebanon....no rescue attempt to bring them up to Israel has been done.............*
Hebron is still populated by the PLO as well as PLO town NABLUS surrounding the Tomb of Joseph....
Yes the call is for Jewish Settlement in GAZA to be rebuilt
https://www.timesofisrael.com/return-to-gush-katif-determined-movement-emerges-to-resettle-israelis-in-gaza/
https://www.timesofisrael.com/government-ministers-call-for-new-settlements-in-gaza-at-ultranationalist-conference/
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/right-wing-israeli-ministers-join-thousands-event-calling-countrys-res-rcna135863
YET JUST Now ISRAEL HAS JUST LOST THE PEACE BECAUSE
https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-starts-allowing-tens-of-thousands-of-gazans-to-return-to-strips-north/
SO Yes Netanyahu has lost the trust of Israel by not making a firm comminment to Secure Peace for the Jewish People everywhere in the World...by making the "Republic of Israel" into Greater Israel devoted to the Torah/Talmud/Oral Law as the People of the Book....thus he should not be the "King" of Israel...
{The following Galat Jewish communities are the exception for rescue:
* The eight Jews in Syria and 3 Jews in Egypt; 3 Jews in Iraq and the 8,500 Jews in Iran....have chosen not to go up to Israel of their own free choice..................
Postscript 1/30/2025:
Since 1931 Bibi you are simply the latest of a modern Jewish Leaders of Israel who have failed in leadership:
Let the ways be counted:
CHiam Weizman-the 1st President of Israel-who disdainfully remarked the Religious Jews from Galat would fade away like dust in the Wind
1) DAvid Ben Avigor Green....your hatred of Religious Jews and Vladimir Jabotinsky; during the 1948 war you stopped the IDF from destroying the Egyptian Army in Gaza and let Judea and Samaria become part of Palestine-Jordan; likewise you counted on the Western Powers to Protect Israel in case of attack by the Arabs instead of relying on the L-D. And the Yemenite CHildren affair happened during your reign as Prime Minister...an action for which the Jewish community from Yemen will never forgive or forget and rightly so.....
2) Moshe Sharrett-a straw man for DAvid Ben Avigor Green
3) Levi Eshkol- you failed to rescue Eli Cohen and Relied on the unreilable United Nations
4) Yigal Allon -the first Sabra to be Prime Minister...who echoded Ben Avigor Green line of "Land for Peace"
5) Golda Mier you and Moshe Dayan nearly caused Israel destruction in the 1973 War by late calling up of the reserves...you sacrificed the career of Chief of Staff
David Elazar as a scrapgaot for your own policies....
6) Yitzhak Rabin...Propoent of the Oslo Accords giving the PLO a foothold in Israel. you posed with a picture with the PLO Leader Yassir ARAFIt
7) Menachen Begin--you sacrified a Jewish Settlement for a Piece of Paper
8] Yitzhak Shamir-- who echoded Ben Avigor Green line of "Land for Peace"
9] Shimon Peres --you posed with Yassir ARAFIt of the PLO with the Nobel Peace Prize-and refused to allow Rabin to bomb HAman's iranian Nucleur Plant
10] Ehud Barak -- who echoded Ben Avigor Green line of "Land for Peace"; you posed with a picture with the PLO Leader Yassir ARAFIt
10] Ariel Sharon-you sacrificed 25 Jewish settlements for a Piece of Paper
11] Edhud Olmert--scandal in office you posed with a picture with the PLO Leader Mahmound Abbas
12-13] Nafatali Bennet and Yair Lapid---you denied teaching the youth of Israel mention of 2nd Temple and the Maccabean Revolt
14] Benjamin Netanyahu you posed with a picture with the PLO Leader Yassir ARAFIt ; you have refused to remove the PLO/HAMAS from Gaza; you trade 30 PLO for 1 Jewish Life; you have not rescuded the Jews of Lebanon; you have allowed Jews to go back to live in galat Nazi Syria
1 February 2025
FAce it Bibi You failed Israel and Hamas won
The Blogs: Such a Deal? FREE HOSTAGES! REBUILD HAMAS—WHAT? | Penny S. Tee | The Times of Israel
Why the “Humanitarians” want Palestinians to stay in Gaza and die rather than leave as refugees - Israel365 News
7 February 2025
Ironically Trump proposal has done something no leader in Israel have done for 105 years...
1) Move all the PLO/FATAH/Hezbullah/Hamas et al out of Gaza to Palestine/Jordan
2) Reconstruct all Jewish settlements in Gaza; Sinai; Judea and Samaria
3) Regard the Israel-Egypt and Israel-Palestine Jordan treaties as dead letters null and void...
Prime Minister Trump | The Times of Israel
Trump's Gaza plan can work- if he de-Nazifies the territory - Israel365 News
https://ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/politics/2025/02/16/rubio-israel-gaza-hamas-trump-netnyahu
Dont wimp out...Bibi...expel the PLO from all of Israel
Israel expels residents of three West Bank refugee camps
Yes to deporting terrorists; no to Hamas immunity
https://israel365news.com/400754/will-the-real-jewish-leadership-please-stand-up/
https://www.npr.org/2025/03/11/nx-s1-5324605/gaza-emigration-israel-trump
Also trump did something Biden didnt
https://www.timesofisrael.com/us-shipment-of-heavy-bombs-held-up-by-biden-administration-arrives-in-israel/?utm_campaign=most_popular&utm_source=website&utm_medium=article_end&utm_content=5
Trump's executive order allows deportation of foreign Hamas supporters
How Biden fueled a 200% surge in antisemitism
The unfunny team of Obuma & Biden..........................
https://israel365news.com/400805/biden-administration-funneled-over-2-billion-to-support-hamas-since-oct-7/
The sad thing is Trump froze USAID for 3 months as of January 20,2025.....it affected legimate programs such as aid to south sudan....trump just threw out the baby with the bathwater..........china;india; UAE ; AU Russsia their infleunce is going to be in South Sudan......not the US.....
Arab "Help" IN Gaza
https://israel365news.com/400845/the-condominiumization-of-gaza/
https://www.timesofisrael.com/aiming-to-stymie-trumps-riviera-vision-arab-leaders-gather-to-endorse-gaza-plan/
Bib its a con dont fall for it.....It will just make Hamas more powerful than ever.......................
Peace in Israel
DEPORT PLO TO SYRIA
https://www.timesofisrael.com/us-israel-see-syria-as-possible-home-for-relocated-gazans-says-report/
Fill Gaza UP with Jews BIBI
Sanhedrin: “Hamas is Amalek, must be entirely wiped out” - Israel365 News
https://torah.org/torah-portion/mikra-5773-terumah/
As Gazans return to school, study finds their PA textbooks still rife with incitement | The Times of Israel
PLO HAMAS IS AMALEK
The Blogs: Amalek and the need to name evil | Mijal Bitton | The Times of Israel
Lawsuit Brings Evidence Anti-Israel Student Groups Had Foreknowledge Hamas Would Attack on Oct 7 - Israel365 News
https://www.timesofisrael.com/idf-tells-gazans-to-flee-entire-rafah-area-in-largest-evacuation-since-fighting-resumed/
https://www.timesofisrael.com/idf-issues-evacuation-order-for-northern-gaza-cities-after-rocket-fired-at-sderot/
https://www.timesofisrael.com/gazans-flee-expanding-strikes-in-north-south-as-idf-says-fighting-entering-new-stage/
Even Now Israel is fighting for its life and yet.......................
https://www.timesofisrael.com/27-us-jewish-groups-file-support-for-detained-anti-israel-tufts-student/
https://www.timesofisrael.com/hamas-urges-uk-court-to-remove-terror-label-claims-group-is-battling-genocide/
Jewish Voice for Peace Exposed: Anti-Israel Group Faces Legal Reckoning - Israel365 News
https://israel365news.com/407361/terror-strikes-in-northern-israel-minister-calls-for-sovereignty-in-judea-and-samaria-and-protesters-remove-fallen-soldiers-memorials-in-jerusalem/
Invade GAZA
Free Hostages
KILL HAMAS
Expel PLO to Syra
Gaza for Jews forever
https://www.timesofisrael.com/katz-threatens-to-annex-part-of-the-gaza-strip-unless-hamas-releases-hostages/
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cq80xqg31x8o
Harvard actions 2025
https://www.timesofisrael.com/harvard-freezes-research-partnership-with-a-palestinian-university-in-the-west-bank/
Fact
0n 3 April, the IDF advanced into Rafah as hundreds of thousands of Palestinians fled the city
???
iran version 4/6/2025 Rafah-wiped-off-map-Israel-ethnic-cleansing-genocide-Gaza
Indonesia and EU Allies of Hamas
https://israel365news.com/407871/indonesia-to-take-wounded-gazans-idf-demolishes-attackers-home-eu-prepares-aid-for-palestinian-authority/
EU no friend of Israel
https://www.thehebrewcafe.com/forum/showthread.php?tid=1571