9 hours ago
is it true to say the yemenite Jews will neither forgive nor forget two things by the Israeli establishment: the forbiding of teaching Torah and Yemenite Childern affair scandal?
There's no indication that the Israeli establishment has "forbid" the teaching of Torah to Yemenite Jews. However, there have been concerns about the preservation of Yemenite Jewish traditions and religious practices within Israeli society, particularly in the context of the Yemenite Children Affair.
Regarding the Yemenite Children Affair, it is widely acknowledged to be a source of deep and unresolved pain for many Yemenite Jews and a stain on the history of the early Israeli state.
Yemenite Children Affair
The Affair: Between 1949-1951, many infants and children of Yemenite (and other Mizrahi) immigrant families disappeared from Israeli transit camps.
Beliefs: Families believe their children were abducted by authorities and illegally adopted by childless Ashkenazi families.
Official Findings: While commissions investigated and concluded that most children died from disease or negligence, many families and advocates strongly dispute this, pointing to inconsistencies and alleged cover-ups.
Impact: The affair remains an open wound, sparking distrust and demands for truth, justice, and accountability from the Israeli government.
Forgiveness and moving forward
Demands: Organizations and families continue to demand official recognition of the affair as a crime, an apology, and community healing initiatives.
Open Wound: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu acknowledged the affair as an "open wound".
Reconciliation Efforts: The Israeli government has offered financial compensation and expressed regret, but has stopped short of issuing a full apology or acknowledging state responsibility, leaving many families feeling that true justice has yet to be served.
While many in the Yemenite community desire reconciliation and recognition, whether or not the pain caused by the Yemenite Children Affair will ever be fully forgiven remains a deeply personal and complex question for the individuals and families impacted by this tragic event.
There's a prevailing sentiment among some in the Yemenite Jewish community in Israel that two key issues remain unresolved and unforgiven:
The Yemenite Children Affair: This refers to the disappearance of babies and toddlers from Yemenite and other Mizrahi immigrant families in the early years of the Israeli state. While multiple Israeli inquiries have found no evidence of systematic kidnapping, families continue to allege abductions and illegal adoptions. The government has acknowledged the families' pain and offered compensation, but has not issued a formal apology or admitted guilt, leading to continued distrust and calls for greater accountability. Surveys show a significant portion of Israeli Jews believe the children were stolen.
Perceived historical pressures to abandon traditional Yemenite Jewish practices and religious teachings: According to the World Jewish Congress, Yemeni Jews faced pressure to assimilate into Western Jewish culture in Israel. While not explicitly a "forbidding" of teaching Torah, these pressures may have been perceived as undermining their unique religious and cultural heritage. Yemenite Jews have a long and distinct tradition of Torah study and interpretation.
It's important to recognize that:
Diverse views exist within the Yemenite Jewish community: Not all members hold the same views or experience the same level of resentment.
The Yemenite Children Affair remains a source of deep pain and calls for justice: The government's actions, while offering compensation, are seen by many as insufficient without a full acknowledgment of wrongdoing.
The issues are intertwined with questions of identity, assimilation, and historical injustice within Israeli society.
There's no indication that the Israeli establishment has "forbid" the teaching of Torah to Yemenite Jews. However, there have been concerns about the preservation of Yemenite Jewish traditions and religious practices within Israeli society, particularly in the context of the Yemenite Children Affair.
Regarding the Yemenite Children Affair, it is widely acknowledged to be a source of deep and unresolved pain for many Yemenite Jews and a stain on the history of the early Israeli state.
Yemenite Children Affair
The Affair: Between 1949-1951, many infants and children of Yemenite (and other Mizrahi) immigrant families disappeared from Israeli transit camps.
Beliefs: Families believe their children were abducted by authorities and illegally adopted by childless Ashkenazi families.
Official Findings: While commissions investigated and concluded that most children died from disease or negligence, many families and advocates strongly dispute this, pointing to inconsistencies and alleged cover-ups.
Impact: The affair remains an open wound, sparking distrust and demands for truth, justice, and accountability from the Israeli government.
Forgiveness and moving forward
Demands: Organizations and families continue to demand official recognition of the affair as a crime, an apology, and community healing initiatives.
Open Wound: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu acknowledged the affair as an "open wound".
Reconciliation Efforts: The Israeli government has offered financial compensation and expressed regret, but has stopped short of issuing a full apology or acknowledging state responsibility, leaving many families feeling that true justice has yet to be served.
While many in the Yemenite community desire reconciliation and recognition, whether or not the pain caused by the Yemenite Children Affair will ever be fully forgiven remains a deeply personal and complex question for the individuals and families impacted by this tragic event.
There's a prevailing sentiment among some in the Yemenite Jewish community in Israel that two key issues remain unresolved and unforgiven:
The Yemenite Children Affair: This refers to the disappearance of babies and toddlers from Yemenite and other Mizrahi immigrant families in the early years of the Israeli state. While multiple Israeli inquiries have found no evidence of systematic kidnapping, families continue to allege abductions and illegal adoptions. The government has acknowledged the families' pain and offered compensation, but has not issued a formal apology or admitted guilt, leading to continued distrust and calls for greater accountability. Surveys show a significant portion of Israeli Jews believe the children were stolen.
Perceived historical pressures to abandon traditional Yemenite Jewish practices and religious teachings: According to the World Jewish Congress, Yemeni Jews faced pressure to assimilate into Western Jewish culture in Israel. While not explicitly a "forbidding" of teaching Torah, these pressures may have been perceived as undermining their unique religious and cultural heritage. Yemenite Jews have a long and distinct tradition of Torah study and interpretation.
It's important to recognize that:
Diverse views exist within the Yemenite Jewish community: Not all members hold the same views or experience the same level of resentment.
The Yemenite Children Affair remains a source of deep pain and calls for justice: The government's actions, while offering compensation, are seen by many as insufficient without a full acknowledgment of wrongdoing.
The issues are intertwined with questions of identity, assimilation, and historical injustice within Israeli society.